Blue Green Deployment vs Canary

By Eyal Katz May 23, 2024

A buggy rollout or, even worse, a security breach can lead to user frustration, lost trust, and damaged reputation. To keep users happy and your brand protected,  you need a robust deployment strategy that balances seamless updates with ironclad security.

32% of customers abandon a brand they love after just one negative interaction. For software teams, this means that every update is a high-stakes moment.  

Can we ensure both a positive user experience and robust protection during every rollout? Blue-green and canary deployment strategies are designed to help developers address the challenges of delivering updates in live production environments. 

Blue Green Deployment: Pros, Cons, and When to Use It

Blue Green Deployment

In the blue-green deployment approach, you have two identical copies of your live server:

  • Blue server with production application.
  • Green server with the latest update.

One of these environments is active at any time, while the other is on standby. This deployment strategy lets you switch between these versions to update your app with minimal downtime.

Furthermore, it allows you to test the new version (green) while the current version (blue) runs. If anything goes wrong with the green, you can quickly switch back to the blue, ensuring a seamless experience for your users.

Advantages of Blue-Green Deployment

The blue-green deployment strategy offers several advantages, making it an attractive option for many organizations. Let’s delve into the specific benefits it provides:

  • Fast Rollouts and Easy Rollbacks: Blue-green deployments have the crucial advantage of quickly switching between production environments with minimal downtime. This allows for swift rollouts of new features and effortless rollbacks if any issues arise.
  • Pre-Production Testing: With blue-green deployments, a complete replica of your production environment is readily available for testing. This identical green environment allows you to thoroughly test your new application version before exposing it to real users.
  • Reduced User Impact: Blue-green deployments aim to minimize disruptions for your users by utilizing separate blue and green environments. Ideally, they won’t notice when you switch between versions, ensuring a smooth and uninterrupted user experience.

Disadvantages of Blue-Green Deployment

While blue-green deployments offer a robust deployment strategy, there are some drawbacks to consider:

  • Cost Implications:  Maintaining two identical production environments can significantly increase infrastructure costs, especially considering factors like AWS region and availability zone selection.
  • Database Challenges: Synchronizing data between the blue and green environments can be complex. Careful planning and implementation are necessary to ensure data consistency and avoid potential issues. A robust cyber resilience framework can help guide you through threat modeling and vulnerability management to minimize risks even during complex deployments.
  • Limited Granularity: Blue-green deployments may not be ideal when updates need to be rolled out in smaller increments. This strategy is typically better suited for larger, more substantial application updates.
  • Security: Even with careful planning, blue-green deployments can leave your application vulnerable to attacks during the switch. Exposed secrets or configuration errors can become easy targets for exploitation.  To mitigate these risks, it’s vital to embed DevSecOps practices into your workflow to catch vulnerabilities before the switch.

Canary Deployment: Pros, Cons, and When to Use It

Canary Deployment

Canary deployment allows you to gradually roll out the changes to a small group of users. Then, once you are confident with the release, you can release it at full scale.

This strategy allows developers to test the new version under real-world conditions with a limited audience, helping to identify and fix any issues with minimal risk.

Advantages of Canary Deployment

Canary deployments offer a way to control the rollout of new features or updates carefully.  It will help to identify issues that only occur under a production load.  However, traditional testing might miss hidden vulnerabilities like hardcoded credentials, misconfigurations, or sensitive data exposure. 

Here’s a closer look at the specific advantages this strategy provides:

  • Real-World Testing: The most significant advantage of canary deployments is gaining insights into your application’s performance under actual production conditions. This real-world testing helps to uncover potential issues that may not have surfaced during pre-deployment testing.
  • Controlled Rollouts: By exposing your updates to a limited subset of users, you can monitor performance and gather invaluable feedback closely. This controlled approach allows you to make necessary adjustments before releasing the changes to your entire user base.
  • Resource-Efficient: Unlike blue-green deployments, which require duplicate environments, canary deployments leverage your existing infrastructure. This results in a more cost-effective and streamlined deployment process.

Disadvantages of Canary Deployment

While canary deployments offer many benefits, it’s essential to be aware of the potential drawbacks associated with this approach:

  • Traffic Routing Complexity: Implementing a canary deployment strategy often involves using specialized load balancers or services that can precisely route traffic to different application versions, adding a layer of complexity to the deployment process.
  • Slow Rollouts: Due to the gradual nature of canary deployments, rolling out updates can take longer than other methods. You’ll need to collect feedback and analyze performance data before gradually expanding the new version’s reach.
  • Data Issues: Data compatibility issues are likely if your application’s new and old versions rely on a shared database. Careful planning and database management are needed to mitigate these potential problems.

Blue-Green Deployment vs. Canary Deployment – How to Make the Right Choice 

Before deciding the best deployment method for your organization or application, you need to compare the pros and cons of each strategy based on your specific needs. 

You can start by asking yourself some questions:

  • What is the maximum downtime your application can afford?
  • Can you afford to double your infrastructure for blue-green deployment?
  • How important is it to have real-world testing before a full rollout?
Blue Green deployment vs Canary Deployment

Blue-green deployment is ideally suited for critical applications that can’t afford any significant downtime. With minimal downtime, fast rollout, and easy rollback, blue-green deployments are ideal for applications like:

  • E-Commerce Platforms
  • Financial Services Applications
  • Healthcare Systems
  • Government and Public Services

On the other hand, canary deployments are widely used for applications that require testing the impact of new updates or features on a small segment of users before a full rollout. 

For example, canary deployment is ideal for applications like:

  • Social Media Platforms
  • Content Streaming Services
  • Gaming Applications
  • SaaS Products

Given the complexity of modern software systems, developers are forced to look beyond blue-green and canary deployments and carefully consider cloud risk management strategies.

Alternatives to Blue-Green Deployment and Canary

Here are three alternative deployment strategies you can use if blue-green deployment and canary are not quite right for your situation and business needs.

1. Hybrid Approaches

A hybrid approach combines blue-green and canary deployments. For example, a prominent online retail platform that regularly updates its infrastructure and introduces new features.

The platform utilizes blue-green deployment for critical upgrades, such as database enhancements or architectural modifications. On the other hand, when rolling out new features, such as a personalized recommendation engine, they can canary deployment.

This combination allows them to get the best out of both methods and balance the cost and reliability.

2. Feature Toggles

Feature toggles allow development teams to discreetly deploy new features, activating them without redeployment for specific user segments or environments.

For example, consider a social media platform rolling out a new dark mode feature. Instead of releasing it to everyone immediately, the platform uses a feature toggle to turn it on for a group of beta testers. This lets the team collect feedback, tweak the feature as needed, and implement privileged access controls to manage permissions associated with these new features.

3. Monitoring

Effective monitoring, enhanced by a well-integrated DevOps toolchain, helps you to detect security issues quickly, allowing for quick action, whether a rollback in a blue-green environment or halting the progression of a canary release.

Furthermore, monitoring allows you to track Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), like error rates and user satisfaction metrics. These KPIs are an essential part of measuring the impact of deployments on non functional requirements.

For example, a mobile banking app introduced a new feature to improve user sign-in. To check its impact, the team monitored essential aspects like how often people could successfully log in and whether there were any error messages. Soon, they noticed more log-in problems for users with older phones. Thanks to this quick insight, they could pause the update for those devices, look into the problem, and work on a solution.

Effective Deployments – Should you use Blue Green or Canary?

Software deployment demands seamless updates and robust security. Blue-green and canary deployments offer distinct paths to achieving these goals, each with advantages and trade-offs. The key is understanding your application’s unique requirements and tolerance for downtime when deciding on the best strategy.

But even a perfectly executed deployment can’t guarantee security. Exposed secrets, misconfigurations, and hidden vulnerabilities pose constant threats. That’s where Spectral shines.  Integrating Spectral into your deployment process gives you an invaluable safety net – automatically scanning your code and infrastructure for potential security risks.  This empowers you to make updates with greater confidence.

Ready to experience the power of secure deployments? Create your free Spectral account today. Let us help you deliver seamless updates while protecting your application.

Related articles

The Developer's Essential Guide to Cloud Deployment Models

The Developer’s Essential Guide to Cloud Deployment Models

You’ll probably agree that there are barely any organizations left that don’t use some form of cloud computing in their daily operations. In fact, the cloud

6 Steps for Success with CI/CD Security Hardening

6 Steps for Success with CI/CD Security Hardening

Rapid digitalization and increasing remote business operations place a significant burden on developers, who are continuously pressured to push out software faster. As a result, CI/CD

The Developer's Checklist to Security Hardening

The Developer’s Checklist to Security Hardening [XLS Download]

The coming of the internet was a beautiful thing, bringing about accessibility to reach everyone across the globe. But this reach is a double-edged sword. If

Stop leaks at the source!